All players on this roster have accumulated more WAR for the Blue Jays than any other major league team. Players are listed alphabetically, followed by their Strat-o-Matic card being used and their position eligibility.
Players without the *** designation are listed in Baseball Reference’s top 1000 in career WAR.
Players with the *** designation are not listed in the top 1000, but are “invitees” to round out the team to fulfill these minimum requirements: 30 players — 18 position players (with at least 2 players rated at each position) and 12 pitchers (at least 7 must have a reliever rating).
Position Players (18)
Roberto Alomar (HOF, 2B), Jesse Barfield (BH, RF/CF), Jose Bautista (BH, RF/3B/LF/1B), George Bell*** (1987, LF/2B/3B), Carlos Delgado (BH, 1B), Josh Donaldson (2016, 3B), Edwin Encarnacion (2012, 1B/LF/3B), Tony Fernandez (BH, SS/3B/2B), Kelly Gruber*** (1988, 3B/2B/SS/CF), Orlando Hudson (2004, 2B), Fred McGriff (BH, 1B), Lloyd Moseby (1984, CF), John Olerud (BH, 1B), Alex Rios*** (2008, RF/CF), Vernon Wells (2006, CF), Devon White (BH, CF/RF), Ernie Whitt*** (1983, C), Gregg Zaun*** (2005, C).
Doyle Alexander (1984, SP), Scott Downs*** (2008, RP), Mark Eichhorn*** (1986, RP), Marco Estrada*** (2015, SP/RP), Roy Halladay (HOF, SP), Tom Henke*** (BH, RP), Pat Hentgen (1996, SP), Casey Janssen*** (2011, RP), Jimmy Key (BH, SP), Paul Quantrill*** (1997, RP), Dave Stieb (BH, SP), Duane Ward*** (1992, RP).