All players on this roster are listed in Baseball Reference’s top 1000 in career WAR and have accumulated more WAR for the Yankees than any other major league team. Players are listed alphabetically, followed by their Strat-o-Matic card being used and their position eligibility.
Position Players (41)
Yogi Berra (HOF, C), Clete Boyer (1962, 3B), Robinson Cano (2012, 2B), Chris Chambliss (1976, 1B), Ben Chapman (1931, LF/CF/2B/RF), Earle Combs (HOF, CF/LF), Bill Dickey (HOF, C), Joe DiMaggio (HOF, CF/LF), Kid Elberfeld (1904, SS), Brett Gardner (2010, LF/CF), Lou Gehrig (HOF, 1B), Joe Gordon (HOF, 2B/1B), Tommy Henrich (1948, RF/1B/LF), Derek Jeter (HOF, SS), Charlie Keller (BH, LF/RF), Tony Lazzeri (HOF, 2B/3B/SS), Mickey Mantle (HOF, CF/LF), Roger Maris (BH, RF/CF), Tino Martinez (1997, 1B), Don Mattingly (BH, 1B), Gil McDougald (BH, 3B/2B/SS), Bob Meusel (1927, LF/RF), Thurman Munson (BH, C), Bobby Murcer (1972, CF), Graig Nettles (BH, 3B), Paul O’Neill (1998, RF), Roger Peckinpaugh (BH, SS), Wally Pipp (1922, 1B), Jorge Posada (BH, C/1B), Willie Randolph (BH, 2B), Mickey Rivers (1976, CF), Phil Rizzuto (HOF, SS), Alex Rodriguez (BH, SS/3B), Red Rolfe (1939, 3B), Babe Ruth (HOF, RF/LF), Alfonso Soriano (2003, 2B), Snuffy Stirnweiss (1945, 2B), Roy White (1970, LF), Bernie Williams (BH, CF), Jimmy Williams (1903, 2B), Gene Woodling (1953, LF).
Bullet Joe Bush (1923, SP/RP), Ray Caldwell (1914, SP/RP), Jack Chesbro (HOF, SP/RP), David Cone (BH, SP), Russ Ford (1910, SP/RP), Whitey Ford (HOF, SP/RP), Lefty Gomez (HOF, SP/RP), Rich Gossage (HOF, RP), Ron Guidry (BH, SP/RP), Waite Hoyt (HOF, SP/RP), Eddie Lopat (BH, SP), Herb Pennock (HOF, SP/RP), Andy Pettitte (BH, SP), Mariano Rivera (HOF, RP), Red Ruffing (HOF, SP), CC Sabathia (BH, SP), Bob Shawkey (1920, SP/RP), Mel Stottlemyre (BH, SP), David Wells (1998, SP).
03/28/19 Dropped Snuffy Stirnweiss (1945, 2B).
04/01/21 Added Red Rolfe (1939, 3B) and Snuffy Stirnweiss (1945, 2B).
03/31/22 Dropped Hank Bauer (1953, RF/LF), Elston Howard (BH, C/LF/1B), and Bill Skowron (1960, 1B).