All players on this roster have accumulated more WAR for the Orioles than any other major league team. Players are listed alphabetically, followed by their Strat-o-Matic card being used and their position eligibility.
Players without the *** designation are listed in Baseball Reference’s top 1000 in career WAR.
Players with the *** designation are not listed in the top 1000, but are “invitees” to round out the team to fulfill these minimum requirements: 30 players — 18 position players (with at least 2 players rated at each position) and 12 pitchers (at least 7 must have a reliever rating).
Position Players (31)
Brady Anderson (BH, CF/LF), John Anderson (1901, 1B/CF/RF/LF), Don Baylor (1973, LF/1B/RF), Mark Belanger (1976, SS), Paul Blair (BH, CF), Don Buford (1971, LF), Harlond Clift (BH, 3B), Doug DeCinces (1978, 3B/2B), Rick Dempsey*** (1978, C), Bobby Grich (BH, 2B), J.J. Hardy (2011, SS), Chris Hoiles*** (1993, C), Baby Doll Jacobson (1920, CF/RF/1B), Davey Johnson (1971, 2B), Adam Jones (2013, CF), Manny Machado (2015, 3B/SS), Nick Markakis (2008, RF), Marty McManus (1922, 2B/1B), Melvin Mora (2004, 3B/SS), Eddie Murray (HOF, 1B), Boog Powell (1969, 1B), Del Pratt (1916, 2B), Cal Ripken (HOF, SS/3B), Brian Roberts (2005, 2B), Brooks Robinson (HOF, 3B), Ken Singleton (BH, RF/LF), George Sisler (HOF, 1B), Vern Stephens (BH, SS), B.J. Surhoff (1999, LF/3B), Bobby Wallace (HOF, SS/3B), Ken Williams (BH, LF/CF).
Mike Boddicker (1984, SP), Mike Flanagan*** (1979, SP), Ned Garver (1950, SP/RP), Harry Howell (1904, SP/RP), Dave McNally*** (1968, SP), Mike Mussina (HOF, SP), Jim Palmer (HOF, SP), Milt Pappas (1959, SP/RP), Barney Pelty*** (1906, SP/RP), Jack Powell (1902, SP/RP), Urban Shocker (BH, SP/RP), Carl Weilman*** (1914, SP/RP).
04/01/21 Dropped Mike Bordick (1999, SS).
03/31/22 Added Mike Flanagan (1979, SP), dropped Mike Cuellar (1969, SP).